Prevention is the key—75,000 infection-related deaths and $33 Billion in costs

Hospitals’ infection-reduction efforts worth their weight in lives, study finds

By Beth Fitzgerald, January 5, 2015,

Elderly patients admitted to intensive care units are about 35 percent more likely to die within five years of leaving the hospital if they develop an infection during their stay, according to a new study released Monday.Preventing two of the most common health care-associated infections — bloodstream infections caused by central lines and pneumonia caused by ventilators — can increase the odds that these patients survive and reduce the cost of their care by more than $150,000, according to a study published in the January 2015 issue of the American Journal of Infection Control.

“Any death from preventable infections is one too many,” said senior study author Patricia Stone, director of the Center for Health Policy at Columbia University School of Nursing. “We’ve known for decades what works to prevent infections and save lives. Now, our study shows just how much money can be saved by investing in prevention.”

The study looked at outcomes for 17,537 elderly Medicare patients admitted to 31 hospitals in 2002 to assess the cost and effectiveness of infection prevention efforts. Then, the researchers used an additional five years of Medicare claims data to assess the long-term outcomes and health costs attributed to health care-associated infections.

While 57 percent of all the elderly ICU patients died within five years, the researchers found that infections made death more likely. For those who developed central line-associated bloodstream infections, or CLABSI, 75 percent died within five years, as did 77 percent of those who developed ventilator-associated pneumonia, or VAP.

Effective prevention programs for CLABSI resulted in an estimated gain of 15.55 years of life on average for all patients treated in the ICU, the study found. Central line catheters deliver life-saving medicines and nutrition. Without proper insertion, utilization, and maintenance, catheters can also transmit deadly infections to the bloodstream. Simple infection prevention measures include hand washing before handling the catheter and immediately changing the dressing around the central line if it gets wet or dirty.

Efforts to prevent VAP resulted in an estimated gain of 10.84 years of life on average for all patients treated in the ICU. Ventilators, machines that force air into the lungs when patients can’t breathe on their own, can cause infections when patients lie flat in bed for long periods of time. Keeping patients elevated in bed, with the head higher than the feet, is one simple precaution that can help prevent pneumonia.

On average, the ongoing cost of running an infection prevention program in the ICU is about $145,000, the study found. Prevention efforts reduced ICU costs by $174,713 per patient for each instance of CLABSI, and by $163,090 for VAP.

“This evidence points definitively to the value of investing in infection prevention,” says lead study author Andrew Dick, senior economist at RAND Corporation.

Betsy Ryan, chief executive of  the New Jersey Hospital Association, said: “It’s a win-win situation when you invest in health care quality and patient safety. The primary goal is to improve care and outcomes for the patient, but a wonderful byproduct of that improved care is the cost savings.”

She said similar results have been achieved in New Jersey by a three-year effort with hospitals under the national Partnership for Patients initiative.

“Our hospitals implemented programs focused on reducing several types of hospital-associated conditions, including the types of infections studied in this new report,” Ryan said. “We found that hospitals’ efforts helped greatly reduce these conditions, and their work in the program’s first two years resulted in cost savings of about $125 million. We’re still compiling the final results of our three-year program, but we firmly believe that this investment is a smart one that pays off in multiple ways.”

Ryan said that, prior to the Partnership for Patients, a NJHA Institute for Quality and Patient Safety collaborative that focused on care in the ICU resulted in a 73 percent reduction in central line-associated bloodstream infections and a 55 percent reduction in ventilator-associated pneumonia. She said using average mortality rate data, those improvements prevented a potential 216 patient deaths.

Health care-associated infections kill an estimated 75,000 Americans a year and create approximately $33 billion in excess medical costs. The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention first linked infection rates to prevention programs in the 1970s. Research since then has shown that checklists and other targeted infection control practices can make a significant dent in infection rates.


The paper is titled “A decade of investment in infection prevention: A cost-effectiveness analysis,” and it was published in the official journal of the Association for Professionals in Infection Control and Epidemiology. Elaine Larson, associate dean for research at Columbia Nursing and professor of epidemiology in nursing at Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health, is a co-author. Other co-authors are Eli N. Perencevich of the University of Iowa, Carver College of Medicine; Monika Pogorzelska-Maziarz, Jefferson School of Nursing, Thomas Jefferson University; and Jack Zwanziger, of the School of Public Health, University of Illinois at Chicago.

The research was funded by the National Institute of Nursing Research.